Test Report for automobile
lifting device. The purpose of the test is to pass ANSI B153.1,
a standard for automotive lifts - Safety requirements for the
construction, care, and use.
Testing conducted
at Cytech
By
David Richards
MAMTC Product Testing Engineer
Test
Parameters:
Return to Top
The engineers at MAMTC
were asked to look at testing a model DP-6 automobile lift for
Cytech. The end result of the testing is certify to ANSI 153.1
standard for auto lifts. The model DP-6 auto lift is a four post
lift intended for use as an auto storage mechanism. It was the
desire of the management at Cytech to pass the ANSI 153.1 criteria
even though the lift is not primarily used in a service environment.
The specification lists several parameters to be considered in
this test. These are:
-
Lift control mechanism
shall automatically return to the neutral or off position
when it is released. When operating the lift, the operator
shall have clear visibility of the lift.
-
On lifts using roll-on
superstructures, the runway surface shall be spaced to accommodate
the tread width of the vehicle. Chocks shall be provided to
restrain vehicle from accidentally rolling off either end
of the runways when they are more than 12 inches from the
lowest possible position.
-
Screws, pins, bolts,
and similar parts used in construction of the shall be installed
with the means to ensure tightness and ease of adjustment.
Fasteners designed for shock loading shall have a strength
factor of no less than 8; those not designed for shock loading
shall have a strength factor of not less than 4.
-
Each lift shall
be provided with a stop to prevent the lift from being raised
beyond the designed limit of vertical travel.
-
All electrical equipment
and wiring shall conform to ANSI/NFPA 70-1990.
-
Lifts shall have
no sharp corners or edges that could cause personal injury.
-
A fully loaded lift
shall not come down faster than 20 feet per minute.
-
Automotive lifts
shall be equipped with an automatic mechanical device to hold
the lift in the fully extended position. The mechanical device
shall have a strength factor of not less than 3, based on
the rated load capacity.
-
All material used
in the construction of the superstructure shall be of the
proper size and characteristic to provide a strength factor
of not less than 3 for ductile metals and not less than 5
for non-ductile metals.
-
All moving parts
except those permanently lubricated must be made with means
of lubrication.
-
Mechanical synchronization
systems shall have a strength factor of not less than 3 based
on the rated load capacity.
-
Air-oil tanks are
pressurized and should be built to conform to Section VIII
of the ANSI/ASME code. When the lift is at full rise, there
should be enough oil in the tank to prevent air from entering
the cylinder. The amount of oil remaining in the tank when
the cylinder is fully extended shall not be less than 3 inches
in depth or 10 percent of the volume or oil required to fully
raise lift. A means for checking the oil level shall be provided.
-
The pumping unit
will withstand 150 percent of the pressure required to operate
the lift at its rated capacity. The pumping unit will be supplied
with a pressure regulator or relief valve seat at not more
than the design pressure of the lift
-
Hydraulic lines
should conform to the provisions of ANSI/SAE J517 MAR88 and
have a strength factor of not less than 4.
-
Valves and fittings
shall be designed to have a strength factor of not less than
3 based on the operating pressure of the lift.
-
Lifts using cable
shall have sheaves, drums, sprockets, and other suspension
members, which have a strength factor of not less than 5,
based on the rated capacity of the lift.
-
Cable used for suspension
shall have a strength of factor of not less than 5, based
on the rated capacity of the lift.
-
Lifts with cable
or chain suspension shall be provided with a slack-cable or
chain device that has a strength factor of not less than 3,
based on the rated capacity, and causes the lift to be automatically
braked if the suspension is broken or slackened.
-
Installation instruction
of lift shall be supplied by the lift manufacturer. The owner/installer
shall comply with these installation instructions.
-
The lift shall be
permanently marked to show the manufacturer's name, rated
load capacity, model, and serial number.
-
Maintenance procedures
shall be provided by the lift manufacturer with each lift
sold.
Return
to Top
The
test article was placed under load and the following was observed:
-
The test article
was a DP-6 lift.
-
A structure was
constructed that allowed the test article to be loaded in
a static manner to a strength factor of 3 based on the rated
load capacity.
-
Paragraph 4.1.3
criteria was observed and found to be in compliance. The load
lever on the power supply did return to off when it was released.
The controls are in such a position that the lift is clearly
visible and easily accessible.
-
Paragraph 4.1.4
criteria was observed and the lift does provide restraint
of the vehicle running off either end of the lift during operation.
-
Paragraph 4.1.8
describes the need for a positive stop. This lift has a stop
provided with the travel of the hydraulic cylinder. With the
cylinder fully collapsed, the cables will extend the lift
only to the designed maximum height.
-
Paragraph 4.1.11
criteria was the main conclusion on the test. The lift was
loaded to a strength factor of 3 for the rated capacity. The
locking device for the lift did conform to the specified strength
factor.
-
Paragraph 4.1.13
criteria was also passed for the safety factor of 3 for the
superstructure. This paragraph states that the ductile metal
superstructure pass the safety factor of 3. This was observed.
Return
to Top
Test
Design:
The test was designed
to load the auto lift with a static load equal to the strength
factor described in the specification. For this lift, this strength
factor was 3, based on the rated load capacity. At the time of
the test, the DP-6 was rated at 6000#. It was also desirable to
see if the lift would withstand a rating of 7000# to change model
to a DP-7. The main criteria for this segment of the test was
paragraphs 4.1.11, and 4.1.14. These paragraphs involved the strength
factor for the superstructure and the locking mechanism. The test
setup is shown in figure 1.

Return to Top
The hydraulic cylinder
used has a 4 inch diameter bore with a 1.25 inch diameter piston
road. The hydraulic pressure on the cylinder was monitored and
translated to force the test article. The loss due to the cylinder
were taken into account when the pressures were correlated to
force. The test fixture on top of the runways which were spaced
at 110 inches to simulate a vehicle sitting on the lift weighed
1239 pounds which was subtracted from the force applied by the
cylinder for the total load.
Test
Results:
The test articles were
placed under load and taken to a level equivalent to 18,000 pounds.
This load represented a strength factor of 3 for a rated capacity
of 6000 pounds. The superstructure and locking devices held
with no signs of failure. The load was then increased to the
equivalent of 21,000 pounds which represented a strength factor
of 3 for a rated capacity of 7000 pounds. This result allows Cytech
to reclassify the model DP-6 as model DP-7. At this load, the
superstructure showed some signs of deflection that constituted
a slight amount of yield in the cross members on the ends of the
lift. This deflection resulted in a slight yield in the cross
members on the ends of the lift. The reason this member yielded
was due to the mounting holes for the caster option being too
close to edge of the tubing as cross members. The manufacturer
observed the problem and stated a smaller hole could be used that
would result in less of a stress concentrator. The cross member
is plenty strong to hold the loads with no stress concentrator,
so with this modification, the member should have no problems
holding the load with no deformation.
With information supplied
by the manufacturers of the cabling system, it was determined
that the provisions of paragraphs 4.3.1.1, and 4.3.1.2, and 4.3.1.4
are all within compliance. At a load capacity rating of 7000 pounds,
the cables will see a load of 1750 pounds each. At a strength
factor of 5, the load carrying capacity necessary would be 8750
pounds for each cable. American Rigger Supply manufactures the
cables for Cytech, and sent burst strength data which stated that
the cable and end connectors had a strength to failure of 15,830
pounds. This nearly doubles the strength factor of 5 required
for the cables.
Return
to Top
The provisions for the
hydraulic system are described in the paragraphs of section 4.2.
The pumping system is purchased as an auto-lift power supply,
manufactured specifically for use on automobile lifting devices.
The manufacturer of the pumping units will need to be contacted
to ensure that the units are up to the specifications in this
standard.
Paragraph 4.1.10 provides
for a maximum speed of lowering the load to the floor level to
be 20 feet/minute. The pumping unit has a built in flow restriction
of 2 gallons/minute. With a cylinder of 3 inch bore and 1.25 inch
piston, the area the fluid acts on is 5.8414 inches square. One
gall is 231 cubic inches and the cylinder moves 1 inch per 5.8414
cubic inch of fluid. At this pace, the DP-6 lift will lower the
load at 6.59 feet/minute. This is well within the maximum of
20 feet/minute.
For paragraph 4.3.1.5,
the standard calls for a brake that will stop the lift from falling
in case of a cable failure. This is a four post lift mechanism
that has 4 independent and separate cable systems that act as
redundant systems. If there is a cable failure on one post, there
are three cables that will act to break the load from falling.
Even if two cables break simultaneously, the cable strength
is still strong enough to prevent a collapse of the load.
All hydraulic hoses
and fittings are purchased parts that conform to the standards
set forth for the safety of users. The manufacturer of these items
are responsible to ensure conformation to applicable standards.
MAMTC
Return to Top
Mid-America Manufacturing
Technology Center
David Richards, Field Engineer
Wichita State University
1845 Fairmount
Wichita, KS. 67260-0146
Phone: 316-978-3676
Fax: 316-978-3677
e-mail: RICHARDS@WSUHUB.UC.TWSU.EDU